Best Greek Food in Wantagh

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Wantagh, NY at 1274 Wantagh Ave

Family recipes, fresh ingredients — since 2017

My Big Fat Greek Bowl

Grilled chicken or lamb over rice pilaf, loaded with fresh tomatoes, cucumber, feta, and a big scoop of house-made tzatziki. This is the one regulars order twice a week.

Order online

Made from scratch, every day

Catering for your next event

We put together full catering packages starting at 12 people — skewers, platters, Greek salad, pita, the works. Call us or order online to get started.

Start a catering order

Simply Greekalicious

Owners Maria and Spiro opened Simply Greekalicious with one rule: no shortcuts. Generational recipes, fresh ingredients, and a genuine welcome — every single day.

Our story

A family kitchen on Wantagh Avenue

Maria and Spiro Ploumes opened Simply Greekalicious to bring bold, honest Greek cooking to Long Island's South Shore — the kind made from real recipes, real ingredients, and a real love of feeding people.

I absolutely love the food here. Not only do they bring it to your table, but the lunch specials are reasonably priced and LOADED with meat! The chicken on the Caesar salad is always marinaded well and tender. There is so much, I almost can't see the salad! Warm pita and TONS of Tzatziki sauce. I cl

Kimberly S.

Tried this through DoorDash for the first time. Never had their food before. I must say I was very pleasantly surprised. The lemon potatoes were absolutely delicious. The chicken was amazing, juicy, and I love that they gave lemon wedges. The chicken lemon soup was also delicious! And the size of th

laura G.

After just one bite of this halloumi wrap, I turned to my husband and told him this is what I want to eat every day for the rest of the summer, if not the rest of my life. I can't always handle how powerful tahihi is, so I got it on the side. Even that was delicious. I have friends coming next weeke

Jessica P.

I’ve been here a couple times now and enjoy it each time Pros : Clean Greek food Served fast Large portions Clean interior Friendly staff Large menu Great sandwich/fries deal Takes credit card ( albeit with charging the fee) Outdoor seating Cons: No lunch menu for a reduced price A bit pricey now f

Andrew T.